electoral reform Archive

  • A polling station in London

    Why was the electoral reform referendum lost?

    The referendum on the introduction of the Alternative Vote (AV) on 5 May was lost by 68 per cent to 32 per cent.  This is a crushing defeat.  What went wrong for the Yes campaign? The explanation can be divided into three possible families of...

    Full Story

  • Winston Churchill, winner of the 1951 general election despite coming second

    Electoral reform: does the winner always win?

    One of the arguments raised by opponents of the Alternative Vote is that it allows the candidate with the second or even the third largest number of first preference votes to win the seat.  This is a clinching argument against AV and in favour of...

    Full Story

  • John Reid (picture Petty Officer 1st Class Chad J McNeeley, US Navy / US Department of Defense)

    “AV is not British”

    Those were the words of Labour peer John Reid speaking at a No2AV press conference with David Cameron this morning, reported by John Rentoul of the Independent.  The interest of most political correspondents lay in the fact that Labour and Tory politicians were on the...

    Full Story

  • William and Kate: how will they vote on 5 May?

    Step out of the 19th century

    There has been some concern among campaigners that, with the royal wedding held only a few days before the referendum on electoral reform, attention might be distracted from the Big Day. But there is something appropriate about two ancient features of our constitution being celebrated...

    Full Story

  • yesbroadcast

    A rotten way to fight a referendum

    There is something unsatisfying about the arguments deployed by the Yes side in the referendum campaign on electoral reform.  They are right that the Alternative Vote is preferable to First Past The Post, but it is not vastly preferable and will not solve all the...

    Full Story

  • FederalTrustlogosquare

    The Alternative Vote Electoral System – the referendum is coming (14 April 2011)

    organised in association with Democratic Audit 14 April 2011, 3.00 – 5.00 pm, followed by a reception Mary Sumner House, 24 Tufton Street, London SW1P 3RB Programme: 15.00 – 15.20: Introduction and Welcome Stuart Wilks-Heeg, Director, Democratic Audit The AV System – The view from...

    Full Story

  • Daylight under Double Summertime (picture from the BBC)

    Time travel: the limits of parliamentary democracy

    A forthcoming proposal to change the time zone raises an interesting question about how our parliamentary democracy represents the diverse interests of this country.  Putting the clocks forward by one hour will be suggested as part of a government tourism strategy to create more jobs...

    Full Story

  • oxbridgepoliticianssmall

    Why are all our politicians so similar?

    A common contemporary complaint is that British politicians are now all too similar.  There is not enough diversity at the top.  (See, for example, “The fall of the meritocracy” by Andrew Neil in the Spectator.)  Andrew Neil sought to criticise the narrow educational background of...

    Full Story

  • A polling station

    AV rewards honesty

    Letter published in The Times, 10 January 2011 Sir, Daniel Finkelstein (Opinion, Jan 5) wonders why supporters of what he calls “pure proportional representation” might support the Alternative Vote. Here are two reasons. First, there is a strategic question. A Parliament elected by AV might...

    Full Story

  • A polling station

    How much difference would AV make?

    In the light of the forthcoming referendum on replacing First Past The Post with Alternative Vote for general elections, an interesting seminar yesterday looked at what difference it might have made to the result of the general election earlier this year.  Of course, there is...

    Full Story